Menu

Order from our selection of homemade cookies, sweets, treats, and more!

 

MENU

A FEW IMPORTANT NOTES BEFORE ORDERING:
- The products listed on our menu are our everyday offerings and always available!
- If you’re looking for something you don’t see listed, submit an inquiry here.

DELIVERY:
- All products are made-to-order and available for local pick-up OR delivery.
- We offer delivery to Greenfield, Knightstown, New Palestine, Cumberland, Fortville, McCordsville, Markleville and Pendleton ONLY .

-All orders have a minimum turnaround time of 72 hours, during the holiday season it may take longer to receive your order. If you need something sooner, please contact me before placing an order.
- Some menu items have Gluten and/or Dairy-Free alternatives. Click on the product to see details.

For large orders please contact me via email: kayla@betterbatterbakery.co

 

Cookie add on

Cookie add on

from $5.25

Cookie Drop – March 26 πŸͺ

Fresh-baked, gourmet cookies available for pick-up alongside your sourdough order.

$5.25 each β€’ Mix + match your favorites

Sampler Bag (1 of each flavor): $15

✨ Just here for cookies? You can order these on their own β€” no sourdough purchase needed.

Ultimate Peanut Butter

A soft peanut butter cookie rolled in sugar, filled with a creamy peanut butter center, and finished with a drizzle of chocolate.

Strawberry Shortcake

Made with crushed Golden Oreos, freeze-dried strawberries, and white chocolate chips for a sweet, fruity cookie with a soft, buttery texture.

Classic Chocolate Chip

A brown butter cookie loaded with dark, milk, and semi-sweet chocolate for a rich, gooey, classic flavor.

✨ Made from scratch

✨ Large, bakery-style cookies (5oz)

✨ Small batch + limited quantities available

⚠️ Allergy Notice:

All cookies are prepared in the same kitchen and may come into contact with common allergens, including peanuts. If ordering multiple cookies (including peanut butter), items may be packaged together.

Flavor:
Quantity:
Add To Cart