Better Batter Bakery
0

Menu

Order from our selection of homemade cookies, sweets, treats, and more!

 

MENU

A FEW IMPORTANT NOTES BEFORE ORDERING:
- The products listed on our menu are our everyday offerings and always available!
- If you’re looking for something you don’t see listed, submit an inquiry here.

DELIVERY:
- All products are made-to-order and available for local pick-up OR delivery.
- We offer delivery to Greenfield, Knightstown, New Palestine, Cumberland, Fortville, McCordsville, Markleville and Pendleton ONLY .

-All orders have a minimum turnaround time of 72 hours, during the holiday season it may take longer to receive your order. If you need something sooner, please contact me before placing an order.
- Some menu items have Gluten and/or Dairy-Free alternatives. Click on the product to see details.

For large orders please contact me via email: kayla@betterbatterbakery.co

 

Easter Cookie Box (PREORDER)

A45329B2-1AC8-417E-A103-F448F8C3C4BD.jpeg
182C963D-AA93-4049-B7AF-1C443B3F9EE5.jpeg
EB0F528B-E21B-4DE2-9AF4-46E722287AF1.jpeg
74DE5A6A-C0B9-42A9-B401-CCB5F1D4ADCC.jpeg
A1231178-340A-4F76-BF29-5A6459B816CC.jpeg
9F0E9F5B-ACA6-47BE-8A0C-CC43EE3637CD.png
A45329B2-1AC8-417E-A103-F448F8C3C4BD.jpeg
182C963D-AA93-4049-B7AF-1C443B3F9EE5.jpeg
EB0F528B-E21B-4DE2-9AF4-46E722287AF1.jpeg
74DE5A6A-C0B9-42A9-B401-CCB5F1D4ADCC.jpeg
A1231178-340A-4F76-BF29-5A6459B816CC.jpeg
9F0E9F5B-ACA6-47BE-8A0C-CC43EE3637CD.png

Easter Cookie Box (PREORDER)

from $30.00

Our Easter collection is here, made completely from scratch in our home bakery.

Each dozen includes two of each flavor:

Brown Butter Carrot Cake, Fudgy Cadbury Egg, S’mores, Strawberry Shortcake, Salted Caramel Cheesecake, and Classic Chocolate Chip.

Baked fresh and boxed for Easter Sunday, April 5, 2026.

Pickup is Saturday evening between 4:00–8:00 PM.

If you need them for Saturday brunch instead of Sunday, please note that at checkout.

How many?:
Quantity:
Add To Cart